Michelangelo of Eastport in Cutchogue

Good pizza, however, this being NY, the standard is GREAT Pizza. I have visited several times for lunch...coke and a slice. Great. Last year (summer 2019) I had several under done pies from these folks, awarded them 4 stars. They have stepped up their game this year ( July 2020). Great pizzas, fully baked. Yum-o. In light of their improved performance, I had to update my rating 5/5. Great pizza fairly priced,

They do not know how to cut up the pizza well and add too much cheese. 👺

Food was fabulous. They are under new management, the chef who was there years ago is back. Service was great!!

Great food, service and consistency

They say they close at 10pm. It’s 9:44. They are closed. Ughhh

Liked the setting, did not enjoy the food.

The worst pizza I’ve ever had in my life!!! Sauce has no taste... cheese is thick and greasy! Just awful!!! Not New York pizza!! Not good!!! Not even close!!!

Always great pizza

Great pizza! the new manager is really good chef. a highly recommended

Finest food, super nice employees, constantly good character. They charge reasonable pricing and the food quality is good. 5 stars.

Great Italian food

Terrible. Just terrible. Cheese tastes disgusting, dough not cooked on the bottom. Not keeping up the standard of Michelangelo’s. Do your tastebuds a favor and go somewhere else.

I love great service and fresh food

Pizza was not warm. Overpriced. No flavor whatsoever. The iced tea was fermented and tasted like alcohol. Sad to say that this is "pizza"

Friendly staff, and the best pizza on the North Fork!

Cute local shop that thankfully sells NY the slice instead of only full pies. Friendly service and cheap prices. The margarita pizza was very nice.

The food is regularly well prepared and delicious, workers hands out great customer service. I liked the cleanliness and character. Will visit here again.

This place is fantastic! Affordable pricing, big dishes and the employees are consistently super nice.

Sicilian and chicken parm slices are incredible

It was okay, I'd go back. Not the best but not bad. A little to crunchy for me.

Great environment and customer service

Best pizza anywhere. Still has the small town pizza joint charm unlike the Mattituck one. Pizza is better quality too.

Yuck uncooked pizza it was horrible

Waited on hold for 10 minutes. Twice. No way Roma Pizza is too busy to take phone orders for pick up. Pathetic

The food is “ OK “ BUT when I call for delivery or just to order ( THEY NEVER ANSWER ) I call for 10 min i they still don’t answer ??? Like what’s wrong I’m just trying to order Food

I visit this place a lot since I work right next to it. I must say their customer service is always fantastic and they keep the place neat consistently. Prices are affordable and they serve sizeable portions.

All new pizza making staff...my experience has been quite good over the last 6 weeks. I will be going back again.

Poor pizza quality and chicken in salad does not taste like real chicken, it’s very “rubbery”. The pizzeria also does not go by their posted business hours and close very early on random nights frequently.

Absolutely the best food, price, and awesome staff

Honestly I wish there were an option for zero stars! I’ve been going to this location for pizza for over 20 year, been there through many different owners and it was always great. However, since it’s been Roma, I’ve gone a few times and had nothing but problems! First of all, their entire system is absolutely horrible! And second how do you run out of everything, even garlic knots, at 5:30 on a Saturday night!! Highly disappointed, and currently finding a new pizza home!

Great pizza. We like the Sicilian and root beer combo!

My business goes to any other pizza place but here. Called an order in to make sure I would get 2 regular slice along with a dinner and chicken roll. Went to pick up food and they were OUT of regular slices at 8:45pm. What kind of pizza place has no regular slices? Called ahead to make sure I got slices, but no slices. Horrible since new owners took over!!!Never again!!

Have not eaten in the rest. area but love the pizzeria and the guys running the show, great service!!

We waited forever for a simple zucchini spaghetti and shrimp dish. It arrived 10 minutes after my daughter's pizza, was bland and so waterlogged it looked like soup. When we complained.they shrugged and said it takes time to spiral the zucchini. Good pizza, avoid the restaurant in the back.

Went for a late lunch and had eggplant and chicken parmesan. Our waitress was super and the food was delicious. I did not know they had a back room and it was perfect.

Hands down the worst pizza on the north fork! I have given the new owners 3 trys. Never again will I go in there again.

Good pizza. Also take out tray of LaSagna was delish.

Great experience. Nice people and food was really good.

The food is well priced, great portions and always consistent. From lunches to quick dinners I have always enjoyed each meal here. The pizza and pasta dishes are not to salty and are still flavor filled. The dining room is well decorated and the service is consistent and quick. The pizza counter is always buzzing and very organized. Call ahead or stop in and order, you will soon add this as your go to destination for quick and easy meals in Cutchogue!

Delicious pizza!!!

Simply put. Just great food.